March 21, 2006

An intoxicatingly frank discussion on…us…today’s Arabs

 

Source MEMRI

Renowned Syrian Poet "Adonis": The Arabs are Extinct, Like the Sumerians, Greeks, and Pharaohs; If the Arabs are So Inept They Cannot Be Democratic, External Intervention Will Not Make Them So

The following are excerpts from an interview with Syrian poet "Adonis," aired on Dubai TV on
March 11, 2006. (Click here to view the clip)

Adonis: "Words are treated as a crime today. Throughout history, there has never been anything similar to what's happening today in our Arab society - when you say a word, it is like committing a crime."

Click “Read More” below to see the whole thing. (It is defiantly worth a read)

I am very interested in getting some Arab opinion on this.

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 14:19:05 | Permanent Link | Comments (21) |

March 13, 2006

To the Islamic Ummah

Muslims against Terrorism petition (h/t sm)

To: the Islamic Ummah

Firmly believing in Allah's divine mercy and compassion, and sharing his love for all his creatures, the undersigned members of the peace loving and moderate majority of Muslims, revolted and repulsed by blasphemous bloodshed in Allah's name, reject as un-Islamic conduct all acts of terrorism including but not limited to:

* school bus attack at Nahariya/Avivim (1970) which killed nine innocent children
* Ma'alot massacre (1974)
* Karni crossing bombing (2005)
* World Trade Center attacks
* Madrid rail bombing
* London rail bombing
* Beslan massacre
* genocide in Darfur
* Bali night club bombings
* decapitation of Danny Pearl
* decapitation of Nick Berg

We condemn, regardless of the identity of the victims, terrorism in all its forms, bombings, shootings, knifings, hijackings, abductions and mass casualty attacks because they do unjust injury to innocent people and irreparable damage to Islam.

We call for the exclusion of incitement to terrorist violence from our madrassah curriculum, kittab & kutbah and from the mass media of all Islamic nations.

We call for withholding Zakat from all organizations which teach, incite, facilitate or organize & perform acts of terrorism.

We call on all Imams and Mullahs to fill their kutbah with Allah's love, mercy and guidance, not with blood thirsty calls for Jihad. We call on the Ulema to reject, as inspired by Shaytan,[22:52] the ayats & ahadith used by radical extremists to rationalize their terrorism.

All this we declare on our own free will, without any hesitation, mental reservation, kitman or al-taqeya whatsoever, by him in whose hand our souls are!

Sincerely,

The Undersigned

Sign it here and encourage as many as you can to do the same and link up.

Please.

- Karim Elsahy

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 08:44:49 | Permanent Link | Comments (9) |

March 12, 2006

Muslim Contributions

How Islamic inventors changed the world

From coffee to cheques and the three-course meal, the Muslim world has given us many innovations that we take for granted in daily life. As a new exhibition opens, Paul Vallely nominates 20 of the most influential- and identifies the men of genius behind them

1 The story goes that an Arab named Khalid was tending his goats in the Kaffa region of southern Ethiopia, when he noticed his animals became livelier after eating a certain berry. He boiled the berries to make the first coffee. Certainly the first record of the drink is of beans exported from Ethiopia to Yemen where Sufis drank it to stay awake all night to pray on special occasions. By the late 15th century it had arrived in Mecca and Turkey from where it made its way to Venice in 1645. It was brought to England in 1650 by a Turk named Pasqua Rosee who opened the first coffee house in Lombard Street in the City of London. The Arabic qahwa became the Turkish kahve then the Italian caffé and then English coffee.

2 The ancient Greeks thought our eyes emitted rays, like a laser, which enabled us to see. The first person to realise that light enters the eye, rather than leaving it, was the 10th-century Muslim mathematician, astronomer and physicist Ibn al-Haitham. He invented the first pin-hole camera after noticing the way light came through a hole in window shutters. The smaller the hole, the better the picture, he worked out, and set up the first Camera Obscura (from the Arab word qamara for a dark or private room). He is also credited with being the first man to shift physics from a philosophical activity to an experimental one.

3 A form of chess was played in ancient India but the game was developed into the form we know it today in Persia. From there it spread westward to Europe - where it was introduced by the Moors in Spain in the 10th century - and eastward as far as Japan. The word rook comes from the Persian rukh, which means chariot.

Click "Read More" to read the rest. 


Posted by Karim Elsahy at 15:45:57 | Permanent Link | Comments (19) |

March 02, 2006

More on Islamism and some on Hizb ut Tahrir al Islami (Islamic Liberation Party)

I have been in correspondence with the man that is becoming our newest regular here, Mr. Abdul-ul-Rahman Hilmi. Having written numerous posts, he defends a hard position and a position hard to defend.

This is an excerpt of information he felt comfortable supplying me with:

"I can tell you that I am a male Arab and part of the Islamic Liberation Party. My views are the views of Hizb ut-Tahrir al Islami."

 


Here are some sources on the Party.

And here, Mr. Hilmi are just some of my qualms.

 

  1. While the status of the Party is currently labeled as non violent there is a lot of preaching to the contrary.
  1. The reason Islam was so successful in the centuries following its initiation was because of its wide appeal. Contrary to popular belief Islam spread primarily through that appeal, much like the current spread of democracy (the current ideology of the day); sure there was conquest, not always all-out war but often through absconding maneuvers, in parallel to Iraq and much of South America and East Asia. But because it is an appealing ideology it took to the people, as does Democracy today; especially as it did in West Africa. Where is the mass appeal in what you are advocating? How does it benefit people that just do not believe in what you do? All we tangibly sees is failure, lack of tolerance, and atrocities in our name.
  1. Even the hawks of our religion will admit that “The People of the Book” (Jews, Christians, and Muslims) are not following a false religion. How do you think a comment like “It turns Islam into just another religion like Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism or any other religion when Islam is so much more.” reflects on that.
  1. The Prophet himself (saws) said that during a holy war the lives of the enemies’ women, children, elderly, livestock, and even vegetation (trees) are the responsibility of every Muslim and their destruction murder. How do you stand in a position to say “resistance by any means necessary” which, and please correct me if my assumption is wrong here, is, I believe, to be advocating suicide bombings that may or may not kill innocents as outlined and defined in Islam.
  1. And what gets me the most, what gets under my skin more than anything, is the mentality that you are right and everyone else is wrong, personified well in “Karim, you SHOULD find the text offensive.” (I didn’t even add the caps) The problem I see in your version of Islam is that it is not content with people getting together and living under a doctrine they like, which is with out doubt your right, but finds it necessary to impose it on everyone. That is the question I would like you to spend the most time on here. Wouldn’t it be a better idea to establish this ideology you have somewhere, flourish first and show the ones you wish to join you how beautifully it is working, and let them come to you instead of what most of us see as empty promises that will result in another failed theocracy of in-toleration like Iran?

 

As I said before:

This is an excellent debate. Abd ul-Rahman Hilmi while you harbor views that are more polarized than most on this site I want you to know your arguments are more than welcome here. You represent a significant portion of Muslims and while I personally feel that that portion is the source of most of our problems I do want to try to understand it better. As long as you have a willingness to genuinely try to understand I promise I will show the same willingness. Perhaps we can learn a thing or two from each other.

To everyone else please continue to show Abd ul-Rahman the respect he has shown so far; try not to let this debate slip into sarcastic retorts.”

This is, to me at least, amongst the most important debates since I started this site. To find someone that shares your view and is willing to correspond openly on these issues is very important to me. So Mr. Hilmi the ball is in your court. Good luck and word of advice; back up everything you say.

-Karim Elsahy

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 13:53:43 | Permanent Link | Comments (60) |

March 01, 2006

A letter on Islamism

 

 

A dozen writers to have put their names to a statement in a French weekly paper warning against Islamic "totalitarianism".

It starts off with:

"After having overcome fascism, Nazism, and Stalinism, the world now faces a new global threat: Islamism."

Sandmonkey adds an important point: “Not Islamic, Islamists. There is a difference”

Most of the signers have had direct experiences with the subject:

Salman Rushdie: Indian-born British writer with fatwa issued ordering his execution for The Satanic Verses

Ayaan Hirsi Ali: Somali-born Dutch MP

Taslima Nasreen: Exiled Bangladeshi writer, with fatwa issued ordering her execution

Bernard-Henri Levy: French philosopher

Chahla Chafiq: Iranian writer exiled in France

Caroline Fourest: French writer

Irshad Manji: Ugandan refugee and writer living in Canada

Mehdi Mozaffari: Iranian academic exiled in Denmark

Maryam Namazie: Iranian writer living in Britain

Antoine Sfeir: Director of French review examining Middle East

Ibn Warraq: US academic of Indian/Pakistani origin

Philippe Val: Director of Charlie Hebdo

 

Here is the body of the text:

After having overcome fascism, Nazism, and Stalinism, the world now faces a new totalitarian global threat: Islamism.

We, writers, journalists, intellectuals, call for resistance to religious totalitarianism and for the promotion of freedom, equal opportunity and secular values for all.

The recent events, which occurred after the publication of drawings of Muhammed in European newspapers, have revealed the necessity of the struggle for these universal values. This struggle will not be won by arms, but in the ideological field. It is not a clash of civilisations nor an antagonism of West and East that we are witnessing, but a global struggle that confronts democrats and theocrats.

Like all totalitarianisms, Islamism is nurtured by fears and frustrations. The hate preachers bet on these feelings in order to form battalions destined to impose a liberticidal and unegalitarian world. But we clearly and firmly state: nothing, not even despair, justifies the choice of obscurantism, totalitarianism and hatred. Islamism is a reactionary ideology which kills equality, freedom and secularism wherever it is present. Its success can only lead to a world of domination: man's domination of woman, the Islamists' domination of all the others. To counter this, we must assure universal rights to oppressed or discriminated people.

We reject « cultural relativism », which consists in accepting that men and women of Muslim culture should be deprived of the right to equality, freedom and secular values in the name of respect for cultures and traditions. We refuse to renounce our critical spirit out of fear of being accused of "Islamophobia", an unfortunate concept which confuses criticism of Islam as a religion with stigmatization of its believers.

We plead for the universality of freedom of expression, so that a critical spirit may be exercised on all continents, against all abuses and all dogmas.

We appeal to democrats and free spirits of all countries that our century should be one of Enlightenment, not of obscurantism.

Now for my Muslim readers the question; would you sign this? Will you actually make the break and commit in writing your name to this text? Read it well.

-Karim Elsahy

 

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 17:58:56 | Permanent Link | Comments (39) |

February 24, 2006

Imam Update

Change of plans concerning my attempt to get the Imam at my mosque to condemn the audacious proclamations of some guy in Pakistan. They apparently have the Imams on some kind of rotation and he just called me telling me he transferred to some Mosque in Chelsea this Friday not MIT. However, he said he will be at the Harvard Prayer Hall next Friday and would make his speech on the Pakistani Imams there. He’s a sweet Moroccan guy. He’s just what a religious guy should be; sweet, gentle, decent, and peaceful. So till next week; Ill keep you posted.

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 15:03:55 | Permanent Link | Comments (1) |

February 22, 2006

Dialoge on Islamic Reformation

I found this deeply interesting and exceedingly intellectual dialogue by following a link to me. I thought I would share. Enjoy.


Evanl:
And by doing that, they are merely reinforcing the stereotype that they are bad people. Counter productive and dangerous.

Noocyte:
Yes, but then there's THIS.

More of this, please. Much more. And faster.

Islam is an Abrahamic religion. Like Judeism and Christianity, it posits an exclusive relationship between the Divine and Absolute Principle of Creation and a "chosen" (essentially tribal) group. At higher levels of abstraction, that chosen group can be extended to include all of humanity, creating the potential beneficial conception of a brotherhood of man (wording intentional; they tend to be rather patriarchal, arising as they did out of primarily nomadic herding groups, and morphing into more agrarian civilizations with a strong emphasis on animal husbandry. Fatherhood/male potency images predominate). On the darker side of things, they can tend to be expansionist/exclusionary...often brutally so (our group has a direct line to the Creator, so all others need to get on board or suffer righteous retribution for their willful ignorance. That sort of thing). ....


Posted by Karim Elsahy at 11:01:31 | Permanent Link | Comments (5) |

February 20, 2006

Holocaust Denier Gets Three Years

Hypocrisy? Yes.

That said, at least there is a pretence to civilized manor. When the Cartoon debacle started I said that though I was offended I was not moved enough to join any boycotts. I argued that utilizing a consumer based boycott was a legitimate means of voicing opinion and getting something that is important to you done. Most in the West are quick to discount that but no one gets to draw the board on which the world plays. Some things are important to some in a way others can not fathom and it is completely within their rights to pursue means, ends, and limitations to those factors that mean so much to them.

I also stressed that as long as they remain non violent they are completely within their rights. What happened next… well no one I know, or want to know, is going to defend that.

To me it is utterly ridicules that someone be imprisoned, be it for scholarly or malicious intent, under “federal law that makes it a crime to publicly diminish, deny or justify the Holocaust.” or any other piece of history. But it was important enough for some Jews, WWII survivors, and descendants of victims to lobby to get these laws instigated. It’s non violent. Sure it’s a very thinly veiled assault on free speech that would never fly in the States but it is not violent. And that satisfies the one unanimous rule you should expect and demand of anyone and most importantly of yourself.

 

UPDATE:

 

An interesting and diverse round up of opinions on the matter by various European news outlets conducted by the BBC.

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 16:03:32 | Permanent Link | Comments (21) |

February 17, 2006

Hell No

Cleric: $1 Million to Kill Cartoonist

UPDATED BELOW

“PESHAWAR, Pakistan - A Pakistani cleric announced Friday a $1 million bounty for killing a cartoonist who drew Prophet Muhammad, as thousands joined street protests and Denmark temporarily closed its embassy and advised its citizens to leave the country.

Police confined the former leader of an Islamic militant group to his home to prevent him from addressing supporters over the cartoons, amid fears he could incite violence, after riots this week killed five people.”

Even in Pakistan that is illegal. That man should be arrested at once and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. His assets should be frozen immediately.

Here is a directorate of almost all Pakistani missions and embassies. Call what’s local to you and demand this mans arrest.

If you are in America write a letter to your rep. Anyone can also call the World Bank and ask them to consider this before increasing aid to $750 million.

Most importantly, Muslims ask your Imams to condemn this in his next sermon.

I’m on my way now to go pray at my mosque in Cambridge and that is exactly what I am going to do.

UPDATE:

I just got back from my mosque. I was late and missed prayers but I talked to the Imam, told him what I wanted him to do, and that, as a journalist, I would be back next Friday to quote and publish him. He will be delivering the sermon at the MIT interfaith prayer hall.

Please try to do the same in your mosque. We can not let this happen.

 

 

-Karim Elsahy
Posted by Karim Elsahy at 11:43:02 | Permanent Link | Comments (46) |

February 16, 2006

Interesting Excerpts from The Economist 2

Mutual incomprehension, mutual outrage

Feb 9th 2006 | CAIRO, COPENHAGEN AND PARIS
From The Economist print edition

Global protests over cartoons of Muhammad, and the jailing of a Muslim in Britain for inciting murder, reveal once more the gulf between Islam and the West

Reuters

WHEN, last September, the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten published a dozen cartoons of the prophet Muhammad, it knew it was testing the limits of free speech and good taste. But it could never have imagined how much. For Denmark itself, this has been the biggest crisis since the Nazi occupation during the second world war. But the implications for the already vexed relations between the West and Islam go far wider. Denmark's prime minister, Anders Fogh Rasmussen, summed it up: “We are today facing a global crisis that has the potential to escalate beyond the control of governments.”

 

Posted by Karim Elsahy at 10:04:03 | Permanent Link | Comments (8) |
1 2